Quantum Storytelling

The Probabilities of Storytelling

Obscurity is Incompetence

Following up on my last post whether creative people hate marketing, Buzz, Balls, & Hype has a great session with the doctor this week, helping a woman who suffers from the very problem I described. She’s despised self-promotion her whole life, and felt it was a compromise to artistic integrity.

The most beautiful part is where the doc addresses her issue with this brilliant sentence;

“Your revulsion at others’ self-promotion may, as you suggest, be proportionate to the degree to which you have suppressed your own need for attention.”

This is a golden observation. I could not have said it better myself. Any time artists rage against crass commercialism, and boast the superiority of being obscure, I can’t help but see the lonely, isolated, nerdy, awkward teenager who isn’t popular, and doesn’t quite fit in the group. Worse, such individuals often feel bitter about their social standing, and lack of attention.

The obvious attitude for a person in that situation is to say things like, “Well, I didn’t want to be popular anyway!” or “Popularity is overrated!” or the age-old “That’s being a sell-out!”

Deep in our hearts, we all know this is a simple rationalization for lack of success. Deep in our hearts, we all know it’s an attempt to compensate, an attempt to justify obscurity and sometimes even mediocrity.

One of my favorite things that Heinlein said was, “Obscurity is the refuge of the incompetent.” Some might find that quote offensive. But look at it this way;

You may be a master of your craft, but if your work is not out there and nobody knows who you are, then how will anyone know that you are the master of your craft?

It has nothing to do with the work. The ‘incompetence’ Heinlein spoke of has more to do with how you handle yourself and your work than the quality of the work itself.

You can be a competent craftsperson but an incompetent PR person for your work, or an incompetent brand manager, or an incompetent business person.

If you are incompetent in these areas, nobody will know or care how great you are as an artist.

When you boil it down, the goal of artists and business people is the same; To share their work with as many people as possible.

Using that yardstick for measurement, obscurity *is* the refuge of the incompetent.

But not all is gloom and doom. Obscurity can be used as simple feedback towards positive results. If you’re not getting the attention you crave, try harder! Set up a book signing, or go talk to a reading club. Start a blog! Start doing things to promote yourself.

You don’t have to settle for obscurity. And you don’t have to feel dirty about self-promotion!

 

Popularity: 4%

Trackbacks/Pings

    Comments

  1. time enough

    I don’t think you’ve ever read the novel from which that quote comes.

    Here it is in context:

    “Mmm, one does have to learn to look at art. But it’s up to the artist to use the language that can be understood. Most of these jokers don’t want to use the language you and I can learn; they would rather sneer because we ‘fail’ to see what they’re driving at. If anything. Obscurity is the refuge of the incompetent.” -Jubal Harshaw (Stranger in a Strange Land)

    As you can see, Harshaw (Heinlein) was not referring to notoriety, but to an artist’s ability to tell a story.

  2. E.v.R.

    The amount you can publicize a book effectively is relative to the ease with which people can identify and understand the subject matter - effective storytelling.

    And yes, I have read the book.

  3. E.v.R.

    Also… the people who most likely can’t tell a good story with a good hook are the ones who subscribe to the notion that more popular writers are ’sell-outs.’

    These are the same people who feel the true purpose of ‘art’ is to marginalize oneself into a corner by creating something no other human on the planet can understand — this is the definition of ‘originality’ to a person like that.

    Heinlein was right in every possible way. Such people are beyond incompetent. And they do use obscurity as a refuge.

Leave a reply