I’ve been quiet the last few days. It’s because I’ve been exploring various open source Content Management Systems (C.M.S.) to see if one of them would work better for some of my websites. I’ve tried PostNuke, phpNuke, Drupal, Joomla, and Mambo Open Source. There’s a writing point at the end of this, I promise. But first, let me give a quick highlight of what I discovered.
PostNuke – Not bad. Templates seem pretty limited, and in the end it ‘felt’ more like a collaborative site tool. Like Wiki, but with an interface. It’s a little hard to explain, but if you take a look at some PostNuke sites you’ll see what I mean.
phpNuke – A lot like PostNuke. Less templates. I didn’t see anything that thrilled me, or that was very different from PostNuke. I’m sure there’s a difference among the hardcore, but I’m not one of those people. I want to build a site fast and hard with as little coding as possible, but with supreme flexibility to make all the kinds of choices I need to make. phpNuke wasn’t it.
Drupal – Drupal scored a lot better in my C.M.S. exploration. Very flexible. Very collaborative. They even have a Book Collaboration feature. That means, you and all your writer friends can login into the main page of your website, and start arranging chapter structures and do your little part of the book.
In the end, I had to pass on this one because it was missing a decent forum plugin/feature, or didn’t seem to interface as nicely as I thought it would. It was also lacking in the template department. All the templates felt very spacious and empty. Maybe that’s just an art/design thing, but if all the Drupal templates end up being spacious and empty in the same kind of way, then Drupal could be to blame?
Joomla – This is supposed to be, “Mambo, but better. And made by the same guys!” Except, I couldn’t make heads or tails of it from Mambo, and after messing with it while I was extremely tired, it just didn’t grab me. To Joomla’s defense, by this point my patience was wearing down a little and I was ready to move on as soon as I realized the tool wasn’t going to do it for me. And it pretty much is the same thing as Mambo. Oh well, you live and learn, right?
Mambo Open Source – This was the one I ended up going with. Why? The interface is very slick, very easy. See what I created with it in two days time. And because I thought Mambo and Joomla were different at first. I tried Joomla when I was exhausted, and Mambo when I wasn’t. Mambo wins! ;-)
Those polls? That’s just a component plugin. The forums? That’s a plugin too. The automatic RSS feed config? You’ve probably guessed it – a plugin. And the best part about all of these? They are completely customizeable. You can tell them to be on the left or right sidebar, or aligned to the top, or bottom. You can order the polls to come before or after the navigation bar, login screen, or syndication feeds. It’s entirely flexible, and entirely up to you.
There are tons of Mambo templates, to make your site look relatively unique. Oh, one more thing–and here’s the real kicker–I’ve only touched like 3-4 lines of code throughout the entire time building AbsurdMarketing.com.
Mambo turned out to be exactly what I was looking for. I’ve been making webpages the hard way for too long. Blogger is ok, but it’s just that–blogging. What if you want a full-featured site? Forums? Sure, you can do that. But none of it will interface with Blogger very well – you’d have to say, install phpBB and then put a link to it in your blog sidebar. That doesn’t gel… not very cohesive. Lots of people do that, and you could to–if your host allows php scripts.
That’s the other problem–right now I’m hosted through Yahoo Domains and Yahoo Hosting. They don’t support php, MySQL databases, CGI executables, etc. If you don’t know what these are, that’s ok. Just know you can’t do shopping carts on your site, or true forums, or anything other than basic websites using html and java/javascript/Flash. So I had to sign up with BlueHost in order to do AbsurdMarketing.com. BlueHost supports everything. They also give you single or double-click installs of things like phpBB or Mambo Open Source, shopping carts, all that great stuff.. All the CMS systems I listed above? BlueHost will install them for you in a few clicks, right to your site. Amazing huh?
I’m seriously considering moving redchurch.com and Quantum over to BlueHost, and building some REAL websites. :)
And now it’s time to get to the writing points. Where are the Content Management Systems for writers and creators? Even for game developers? We have very few.
What I’m talking about is this; How much time do you waste formatting things, setting things up, getting things ready, scribbling notes on paper, assembling notes, thoughts, and ideas–practically slaving over these things just so you can finally get to the point where you actually write? I don’t know about you, but I waste a lot of time on non-writing tasks that are prerequisites for the writing.
Sure there’s yWriter, which is great–I’m using it for my rewrite. There’s FreeMind, which I’m also using. I love these tools. But I have to admit, as in all likelihood you will too, they are not Content Management Systems. Some of their features border on C.M.S. But they are not C.M. Systems.
So until we get our Writing Content Management Systems, we will have to continue doing things the Hard Way instead of the Smart Way.
But in the meantime, check out something like Drupal. It might give you some ideas.
Oh yeah, and before I forget–one more plug… here’s Absurd Marketing. I built it in two days without touching much code at all, using a web-based click-driven interface.
Where is the writing C.M.S., indeed.
Recent Comments