Apr

03

Writing Easy, Storytelling Hard

Posted by : E.v.R. | On : April 3, 2007

Most people can string two sentences together. And if prodded, they can string another two sentences, and another. They can tie those sentences into a paragraph, and those paragraphs into a page. Many believe these are the baby steps that produce a book. And at some point, they inevitably do. What’s the old saying about monkeys and typewriters?

Writing doesn’t make a good story. Neither does editing, although it can certainly make a good story great. Just because we’ve written a bunch of characters doing a bunch of stuff across 200 pages doesn’t mean we’ve got a decent story. That requires a whole different skill from just hammering away at the keys. It is an exercise of the mind to work out times, places and events. It is a more difficult exercise to make those things believable and logical.

The job of the storyteller is that of Coherer — bringer of coherence. To me it adequately describes what the writer does; taking incoherent bits and pieces and making them coherent with the overall facts and progression of the story.

When somebody mentions writer’s block, I’m often reminded that it means something different to each of us. For some people writer’s block occurs in the literal sense of the term; They simply can’t write. They can’t sit down and put words on the page.

The other kind of writer’s block is one where the writer can sit down and hammer away at the keys, but come away feeling no better, no further along in story, no more progress than the previous day. I happen to fall into this camp. I can write, and write, and write. I can be downright hypergraphic at times. But it does me no good if my story isn’t going where I want it to. I’m writing in vain. My pages are a waste. Throw them all out!

My block is a block of ideas. It is a block from forming the proper connections between two parts of a story, which leads me to a another class of blocked writers. I believe there are some writers who believe their block is of the first kind. They sit down and stare at the blank page, and think “I can’t write! I just can’t get the words out!” This is usually because they don’t have a story to tell. It hasn’t fully formed yet. Something is missing. Something essential, that once in place, makes writing easy. Because when you’ve got something to say, and you’re excited and passionate about it, the words just flow, don’t they?

That’s because writing is easy. Storytelling is hard.

Comments (7)

  1. SMD said on 03-04-2007

    I’m a little bit of the same and a little bit different when I get ‘writer’s block’, which to me is little more than my brain telling me to either take a break or stop being a lazy bum and actually write something. What I tend to do is do something that clears my head. For me, that is a video game that doesn’t require much thought–some sort of first person shooter perhaps. Usually in about 20 minutes my brain is back in action and ready to write.
    And it is hard to tell a good story as opposed to writing one…just like it is hard to start a bran new essay for a class than it is to finish it…

  2. Corvus said on 03-04-2007

    I agree that the two skills are dramatically different and that writing is the easier of the two.

    Speaking of storytelling Eric, can I add you to the list of peer reviewers for my upcoming Storytelling Whitepaper?

  3. Eric von Rothkirch said on 03-04-2007

    Corvus, I’d be happy to take look.

  4. Nienke said on 03-04-2007

    Exactly! All of the above. ;)

  5. strugglingwriter said on 03-04-2007

    I wrote a post the other day about writer’s block and how I didn’t thihk I experienced it, but now you mention it I am suffering from the type of block you are talking about. I’m writing stuff, but the story is just not forming.

  6. Eric said on 03-04-2007

    Having done NaNoWriMo twice now, I’ve realized that I don’t have a writing problem. Even outside of NaNo I can force myself into little writing spurts.

    The only time putting words to the page helps is if those words forward the story. When they don’t, then I’m no better off for writing them.

    This is one of the things that has set me off on the quest for the perfect plotting tools. It may be an erroneous quest for the holy grail, and I realize I probably won’t find what I’m looking for… but I have to try, and it’s what I discover along the way that makes it worthwhile.

  7. [...] think I’m experiencing writer’s block in the normal sense, more like the type described in this post on the blog Quantum [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *