TV Studies: Dexter & New Amsterdam
Dexter
Everyone has been raving about Dexter. I finally got around to watching the first two episodes. I like it a lot. Being a huge fan of the film Mr. Brooks, Donald Westlake’s novel The Ax, and the video game Hitman, I have perhaps an unhealthy appreciation for anti-heroes of the darkest sense. I do recognize, however, that my sensibilities are subjectively mine — and only mine. Which is why I was curious how Dexter’s creators would make a serial killer sympathetic to a wider audience.
They’ve done a great job. Not just because he kills people who deserve it: other killers, rapists, pedophiles. But because they do a great job of also portraying his lack of proper social emotions and justifying his moral compass through flashbacks with his father. Dexter is an excellent example of making the extreme anti-hero into a likable and even humorous character. You might glean a few characterization tips from watching the show, and it’s just plain enjoyable viewing to boot. Give it a try.
New Amsterdam
John Amsterdam is an immortal. He cannot die unless he finds his true love. Oh, the tragic irony. Being a child of the 1980s, I can’t help the unavoidable comparisons to the movie and TV series Highlander. New Amsterdam holds a few interesting twists.
First though, let me be honest in saying I probably wouldn’t have moved forward on this concept without at least a few more unique elements. I’m much more fascinated to watch this series by finding out where and how the creators differentiate from Highlander or any number of vampire movies. Immortality is a pretty narrow theme to explore, and I think doing so without being immediately compared to the most obvious familiar works is downright impossible.
That said, New Amsterdam differentiates in some interesting ways. One of them is that the main character (also named Amsterdam) doesn’t seem to care all that much about keeping his immortality a secret. In fact, the world is so harsh and uncaring that nobody believes him anyway. This becomes a source of humor, with character interactions such as;
Amsterdam: “This nightclub used to be a speak-easy during the prohibition.”
Partner: “How do you know?”
Amsterdam: “I used to drink here.”
*Cue baffled reaction shot of partner.
There’s such a high level of plausible deniability in the idea of immortality, that the main character doesn’t have to hide his nature at all. This is a refreshing take, and avoids the obvious cliche of hiding a secret identity. It also adds a lot of humor.
It’s too early to say whether the show has legs, but I’ll keep watching for a little while out of creative interest alone.
Trackbacks/Pings
Leave a reply
Comments
March 18th, 2008 at 4:18 pm
What I like most about Dexter’s portrayal of his lack of proper social emotions is that I think he’s totally wrong and his Dad mislead him. That juxtaposition is what makes this show so delightful.
Hi Eric!
March 19th, 2008 at 7:17 pm
I just like that someone is creatively approaching the idea of a serial killer as an anti-hero, and not being afraid to go to those dark places and also make humor out of them from time to time.
This is a theme that someone who is too creatively timid would not approach.
I think the solid plotting, pacing, and overall quality of writing reflects this as well.