Archive for the 'Rants' Category
Sacrifice In Stories
Do you like happy endings? Or do you like tragedy? Does the hero have to ride off into the sunset, having saved the day and living happily ever after? Or are you okay with the hero or heroes dying in order to accomplish their goal?
For me it’s all of the above. I like it all, on one condition; The sacrifices have to be meaningful.
I don’t read stories or watch movies to find out that change is impossible and the hero ultimately fails. And yet storytellers still pull these kind of shenanigans.
7 comments
The Myth of Formula
In the unusual amount of freedom allowed to me by the Thanksgiving break, I managed to see The Mist and No Country for Old Men, both movies adapted from stories by popular authors.
I’ve read The Mist short story by Stephen King, but haven’t read No Country for Old Men, by Cormac McCarthy of “The Road” fame.
Both involve strong characters stuck in sticky dilemmas, forced to make hard choices which the audience may or may not agree with. But wait! Doesn’t the title of this thread imply this post was about Hollywood and formula?
Well here it is; Formula is officially dead. Or maybe it never existed. Love it or hate it, these movies break a couple fundamental rules. Rules that, if there were such a thing as The Formula, are clearly being violated in Hollywood left and right.
No comments
Politics In Fiction
Lois Tilton over on Deep Genre has a problem with libertarianism in stories. Though I think in her reaction, she’s a bit heavy-handed herself in two ways:
- She implies that getting too political or philosophical in fiction makes the reading less enjoyable, and more a rolling-of-the-eyes.
- She oversimplifies libertarianism as an Ayn Rand-ian, anti-social, “greed is good” selfishness, and in the process shows her own true colors a bit strongly — see number one.
Speaking of tautological knee-jerk reactions, I played the Bioshock demo and noted much of the same. The antagonist in the fictional underwater city of Rapture is one Andrew Ryan (Ayn Rand - Andrew Ryan, get it?) and of course the player is lambasted with sound bites that echo of Gordon Gecko in Wall Street.
4 comments
